Bethel Bakery | Bakeries at 5200 Brightwood Road - Bethel Park PA - Reviews - Photos - Phone Number

Bethel Bakery

1204 reviews
 5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102US

Write a review

Rating Error
Review Error
(412) 835-6658

Write a review

All reviews summary

1203 reviews
  • 438 reviews4.9
  • 282 reviews4.9
  • 184 reviews5.0
  • Show All
4on Trip Advisor, Oct 02, 2017
Got a Blackberry Pie. It was great, but was expensive - $16.25. Everything, I ever had at this bakery was very good, but be prepared to pay more. more »
5on Wedding Wire, Sep 30, 2017
Very happy with our 100 cupcakes and two tiered wedding cake that we had. Got so many complements! Thank you very much Bethal Bakery! You made my dreams come true more »
5on Trip Advisor, Sep 27, 2017
Ordered a 1/4 sheet cake for my daughter's birthday. I usually order from local grocery store which I thought was good however, when I ordered from Bethel Bakery, it's amazing how many people asked, "Where did you get the cake from?!?" Their icing is perfect and not too sweet or gritty. The decorations were beautiful. more »
Business Response:
Hi, Beth! We are so glad you enjoyed your cake and thank you for choosing Bethel Bakery!
5on Facebook, Sep 27, 2017
Best experience EVER working with their wedding staff!! more »
5on The Knot, Sep 24, 2017
Bethel Bakery was amazing to work with! Everyone was super friendly, they have the most wonderful customer service, and their cake and cookies were loved by everyone! Our wedding cake turned out better than imagined. We also ordered cookies for the Pittsburgh cookie table, and they were a huge hit! I cannot recommend Bethel enough! more »
3on Facebook, Sep 23, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Sep 23, 2017
Awesome Bakery!
Excellent Customer Service!
Delicious baked goods!
more »
Business Response:
Thank you!!
5on Facebook, Sep 22, 2017
We had a cake made for my Hubby's 50th last weekend. I had a Polish Eagle image on it and EVERYONE commented that it was the most beautiful cake they have seen. It was absolutely amazing. Your artists are in a class by themselves. Thank you so much for making this delicious and beautiful dessert to finish our celebration! more »
Business Response:
We are glad you enjoyed your cake, Tammy!
5on Facebook, Sep 19, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Sep 14, 2017
more »
4on Facebook, Sep 12, 2017
There was the most beautiful cake with roses on it that I ever saw more »
3on The Knot, Sep 09, 2017
I was excited to work with Bethel Bakery because of all the great things I've heard about them. This was my first experience ordering through them, and the ordering process, appointments, etc - was an easy task. We had arranged for cupcakes and a small cake on the top for my wedding recepetion. The reason for my 3 star review, is because I was a little disappointed that there were no "left over boxes". What I mean by this, is at the end of the night, with the left over cupcakes, we were scrambling to find some sort of boxes to put them in to take home. We did mention this when returning the cake stand, and we were told if we needed boxes - it was to be arranged prior to the event. Honestly, I had not even thought about that beforehand; and I would think with all of the money/time we were spending, that it should have been brought up by a consultant at some point. The cake itself tasted great, though. Just not sure if I would use again for a future event. more »
5on Facebook, Sep 08, 2017
Along with all the delicious pastries there coffee an donuts are excellent! more »
5on The Knot, Sep 04, 2017
Bethel Bakery was great to work with! Our guests loved our wedding cake. We even barely had any leftovers!! From the consultation appointment to the final product we were extremely pleased with Bethel Bakery! more »
5on The Knot, Aug 29, 2017
Thank you so much to Bethel Bakery! The cake tasted absolutely amazing and oh so beautiful!!! more »
5on The Knot, Aug 29, 2017
Delicious cake and beautiful design. Easy to work with and they made sure that our cake's design didn't melt in the hot August sun since the cake was displayed outside. Everyone loved the taste and the design fit our rustic theme perfectly. more »
5on The Knot, Aug 27, 2017
We had an overall amazing experience at Bethel Bakery! The cake tasting was extremely helpful and fun, the staff were all super friendly and accommodating, and our entire list of wedding guests couldn't get over how beautiful our cake was. Bethel Bakery is hands down #1 in the industry!! more »
5on The Knot, Aug 25, 2017
Bethel Bakery is known for their desserts and cakes. There is a reason for that! Our wedding cake came out beautiful and delicious. It really was a masterpiece. All of our guests enjoyed the cake and the cookies at our cookie table. They can do it all! more »
5on Facebook, Aug 25, 2017
Bethel Park Bakery is the Best Bakery! Love all their bakery goods. I bought my mother a beautiful cake for her 90th Birthday. It was swirled in beautiful roses and absolutely delicious! Number one bakery! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Sandy!
4on Trip Advisor, Aug 21, 2017
Travelling through the BP area and just needed to stop in, check out the selection and get some nut rolls for breakfast. The interior is about the same, the counter help is the same only the faces are different, and the selection is consistent. Now this is a classic and landmark in BP and Pittsburgh, so things here have to remain constant. The nut rolls were good as was a square of carrot cake for an afternoon sugar fix. Not much humor with the counter help (one friend with me had worked there years ago and noticed that difference too). I guess at the morning rush, the atmosphere would be different. Nice view of the new fire station too! more »
5on Facebook, Aug 15, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Aug 11, 2017
Picked up donuts at the store on 19 between Washington and McMurray. Freshest donuts ever! Bethel Bakery has nevered failed me...cookies, cakes, donuts...yum! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Renee!
5on Facebook, Aug 11, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Aug 11, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Aug 11, 2017
more »
Page 5 of 37

Google reviews summary

282 reviews


5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Today 7:00 am - 7:00 pm


Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes.

With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna.

Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of the busiest and most beloved purveyors of high-quality baked goods in western Pennsylvania. And they did it while raising seven children, all of whom would eventually work in the family business.

Today, a second generation of the Walsh family manages the bakery. John and his wife, Chris, took over day-to-day operations in 1991and expanded the already extensive inventory of baked goods, but Morris and Anna’s legacy of exceptional quality and customer service lives on.

People travel for miles for a taste of Bethel Bakery’s signature buttercream icing and discriminating brides across the region wouldn’t dream of celebrating their nuptials with anything but a hand-crafted, custom-designed Bethel Bakery cake decorated by one of the shop’s talented designers.

In 2006, Bethel Bakery’s iconic status in the region was recognized by award-winning documentary filmmaker Rick Sebak, who featured the bakery in his WQED program, “What Makes Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.”

In an era driven by convenience and competition from mega-markets and chain stores, Bethel Bakery has endured because it is far more than just a retailer of baked goods—it is an memorable destination experience and a nostalgic reminder of the charms of independent bakeries that were once part of the fabric of every community.
more »