Bethel Bakery | Bakeries at 5200 Brightwood Road - Bethel Park PA - Reviews - Photos - Phone Number

Bethel Bakery

1204 reviews
 5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102US

Write a review

Rating Error
Review Error
(412) 835-6658

Write a review

All reviews summary

1203 reviews
  • 438 reviews4.9
  • 282 reviews4.9
  • 184 reviews5.0
  • Show All
5on Facebook, Nov 30, 2017
Thank you, Thank you, Thank you! This is the place that you want making your wedding cake! I knew from the April appointment (this is the only bakery of the 4 that we were looking at that would accommodate my work schedule so huge A+ there) that this is where I wanted my cake from. The staff was both professional and polite, they answered every single one of my questions quickly, they were able to help coordinate the delivery of a special order from the Gluuteny to my venue, the cake was AMAZING! We had the white almond with the raspberry buttercream filling and it was all my guests talked about. We had the outside done as a skim, which my guests also thought was really neat and special. A+, outstanding, and I can't wait for my next order. more »
Business Response:
Hi Amanda, Thank you for sharing your experience of working with the Wedding Department at Bethel Bakery! It was an honor to be a part of your wedding and we are thrilled that you and your guests enjoyed the look and taste of your wedding cake! We wish you a lifetime of joy and happiness and look forward to seeing you soon!
5on Facebook, Nov 21, 2017
more »
5on The Knot, Nov 21, 2017
I think that if you're from Pittsburgh, you already know how amazing Bethel Bakery is, and how delicious their desserts are! My experience working with Bethel Bakery was nothing less than super impressive and amazing. My husband and I met with someone from Bethel Bakery twice before our wedding to design our cake - they were so easy to work with and we could tell how truly passionate they were about wedding cakes. Our wedding cake was BEAUTIFUL! I couldn't have asked for anything more. We will definitely use them in the future for any event or party for cakes and desserts! more »
5on BirdEye, Nov 18, 2017
Bethel Bakery created my son's 3rd Birthday cake - it was so easy to order online and pickup and was EXACTLY, if not better than what I had envisioned on the outside and I can honestly say I';ve never tasted a cake that delicious. It is rare to find somewhere that exceeds all of your expectations and then some -- I am a lifetime customer! Thank you! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Chelsea! We are so glad that you were happy with your cake and we hope you had a fantastic party for your son!
5on Wedding Wire, Nov 18, 2017
My husband and I decided to have a cookie table at our reception at the very last minute. We placed our cookie order of about 30 dozen cookies online on Tuesday, then picked them up on Thursday. The process was painless, and the guests LOVED the cookies!! more »
5on The Knot, Nov 17, 2017
AMAZING bakery! They were easy to schedule an initial meeting with. They helped us pick out a design and colors-we didn't really know what we wanted because Pinterest can be overwhelming! They even worked with our florist because we got real flowers placed on our cake. They worked with us for a budget friendly option as well. We ordered a three tier cake along with back up cakes that reduced our cost by a few hundred dollars. The cake was delivered without any issues and our cake toppers were placed flawlessly. Everyone loved the pumpkin flavor that we had for our September wedding and said that it was a beautiful design. We also went home without any of the back up cakes, which were different flavors because everyone ate so much! more »
5on Facebook, Nov 14, 2017
Everything is delicious. My favorite are the buckeyes. Customer service is top notch too. more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Cammi!
5on The Knot, Nov 12, 2017
I am so glad we chose Bethel Bakery for our wedding! We only had to meet once with them to discuss our vision for what we wanted and they outperformed what we expected! Everything was beautiful, tasted great, and was delivered without a hassle. Every member of the staff that we spoke with were very friendly and willing to do what they could to accommodate us. I highly recommend using Bethel Bakery! more »
5on Facebook, Nov 10, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Nov 09, 2017
more »
5on The Knot, Nov 07, 2017
We booked our cake about 1 year in advance with Bethel Bakery. We were planning our wedding from a different state and they were able to squeeze us in for a tasting during one of our visits. We felt so special during the tasting and the cake was super yummy so we immediately decided to book them! We are so glad we did because our cake turned out exactly how we wanted!! It was gorgeous and tasted amazing! It's going to be super hard to wait until our 1 year to eat the top tier. more »
5on Facebook, Nov 07, 2017
Bethel Bakery created an amazing cake for my parents’ surprise 50th wedding anniversary. It replicated the one at their reception fifty years ago. So beautiful! Thank you again for making their day extra special! more »
Business Response:
You’re welcome, Jesse! Thank you for letting us be a part of that special day!
5on BirdEye, Oct 31, 2017
Bethel Bakery in Bethel Park did a cake for me last minute for Halloween, it was beautiful, they are always pleasant and great to deal with, and always do amazing work! more »
5on Facebook, Oct 28, 2017
I love this place!!!! I want their cakes all the time ������ more »
Business Response:
We have two locations! Bethel Park is 5200 Brightwood Rd and North Strabane is 2500 Washington Rd ☺️
5on Wedding Wire, Oct 28, 2017
Bethel Bakery designed both my bridal shower cake and the groom's cake for our rehearsal dinner. Not only are all of their batters and fillings delicious, but their cake decorating is flawless. more »
5on Facebook, Oct 24, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Oct 16, 2017
Bethel Bakery made our cake for our wedding this past Saturday, and it was delicious!! We went with the yellow cake with a pumpkin spice filling and vanilla bean filling. The cake was so moist, and I heard no complaints! The staff was wonderful to work with, and everything looked great! Thank you!!! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Jessica! We are so glad you enjoyed your cake!
5on Trip Advisor, Oct 14, 2017
From cakes to cookies to donuts everything they make is out of this world good bit the cakes just simply can not be beat!!! I personally like adding the raspberry filling to mine and OMG is it to die for!!! Try it today or ASAP!!! more »
5on Facebook, Oct 13, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Oct 10, 2017
Has been a favorite since we got our wedding cake there 3O years ago. Never disappointed. more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Ruth!
5on Facebook, Oct 10, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Oct 09, 2017
Oh my Son and Daughter inlaw always go there .....They got my Birthday Cake there it was EXCELLENT !!!! Anything they but there never Disappointed � more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Kathy!
5on The Knot, Oct 08, 2017
the cake was perfect, wonderful guest services more »
5on Facebook, Oct 06, 2017
The bakery foods are AWESOME. LOVE THERE CHOCOLATE CAKE WITH CHOCOLATE ICING. I REALLY HAVE'nt found anything I didn't like. Great Bakery. more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Sherry!
5on Trip Advisor, Oct 03, 2017
most delicious bake goods in the 'burgh. Cream fill donuts are to die for.
Why buy an 8" bundt cake for $22 at the competition when Bethel Bakery 8" cake is more affordable for $8.99. somet
hing for everyone and zero calories!! more »
Page 4 of 37

Google reviews summary

282 reviews


5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Today 7:00 am - 7:00 pm


Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes.

With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna.

Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of the busiest and most beloved purveyors of high-quality baked goods in western Pennsylvania. And they did it while raising seven children, all of whom would eventually work in the family business.

Today, a second generation of the Walsh family manages the bakery. John and his wife, Chris, took over day-to-day operations in 1991and expanded the already extensive inventory of baked goods, but Morris and Anna’s legacy of exceptional quality and customer service lives on.

People travel for miles for a taste of Bethel Bakery’s signature buttercream icing and discriminating brides across the region wouldn’t dream of celebrating their nuptials with anything but a hand-crafted, custom-designed Bethel Bakery cake decorated by one of the shop’s talented designers.

In 2006, Bethel Bakery’s iconic status in the region was recognized by award-winning documentary filmmaker Rick Sebak, who featured the bakery in his WQED program, “What Makes Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.”

In an era driven by convenience and competition from mega-markets and chain stores, Bethel Bakery has endured because it is far more than just a retailer of baked goods—it is an memorable destination experience and a nostalgic reminder of the charms of independent bakeries that were once part of the fabric of every community.
more »