Bethel Bakery | Bakeries at 5200 Brightwood Road - Bethel Park PA - Reviews - Photos - Phone Number

Bethel Bakery

1007 reviews
 5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102US

Write a review

(412) 835-6658

Write a review

4.6on Wedding Wire, Jul 22, 2017
Bethel Bakery lived up to their high reputation! We sat down with Chelsea to taste test & design my cake. After we taste tested and picked out the cake, I only had to pay for it & wait for my wedding day where they take the cake to the reception & set it up for you! SUPER EASY & stress free! They even called me the week before to make sure my guest count was accurate & that I didn't need any back up cakes, just in case I forgot. When I walked into my reception it looked exactly how I designed it! And it tasted GREAT! A little pricy, but I designed my own cake. I definitely recommend!! more »
5on The Knot, Jul 19, 2017
They did an awesome job for our wedding cake!! The design was very elegant plus our guests gave us a lot of compliments regarding the taste. The staff was also wonderful with communicating with us during the planning process and also very accommodating when I changed my mind a few times. Definitely highly recommend! more »
5on The Knot, Jul 17, 2017
Our wedding cake was SO AMAZING and several of our guests raved about it. The process of selecting a cake, the tasting, and ordering were extremely simple. Bethel Bakery offers many delicious options! I am looking forward to eating the topper next year (if I can leave it in my freezer that long without giving in and stealing a bite!) more »
5on Google, Jul 16, 2017
Pastries galore here! If you have a need for sweets, bread, pastries, danishes, cookies, cakes, look no further. This local shop has been amazing for many years. Nut rolls, yum-yums, doughnuts...seriously. If you have 5 minutes extra on your drive go here. Customer service can help with everything. Be careful, they'll leave you coming back for more...or they could run out of the good stuff before you get there. Go early! more »
5on Google, Jul 16, 2017
Best cakes around! Great staff ! more »
5on Facebook, Jul 16, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Jul 13, 2017
Best Bakery in the South Hills!!! Great Food & Service!!!! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Matt!!
5on Facebook, Jul 11, 2017
Yesterday we picked up our sons 4th birthday cake. He wanted a fishing theme cake so bad and we must have called every Bakery in the area and surprisingly nobody does fishing theme cakes....except Bethel Bakery!!
When we got home with the cake and showed it to Wyatt these were his exact words...
"It's everything that I wanted I love it mom"
Thank you for going above and beyond (as always) and making this little guy so happy on his birthday!!
It was white cake with traditional French buttercream icing and it was delicious!! Not sure who the decorator was but can you PLEASE give them my sincerest thank you for doing such an amazing job!
I will post picture in the comments below!
more »
5on Facebook, Jul 10, 2017
They did an amazing job w/ our wedding cake! We received compliments all night and still get questions about it to this day! Everyone was super helpful and wanted to make sure we had our dream cake. Definitely recommend them! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Christina! We were honored to be a part of your special day!
4on Trip Advisor, Jul 10, 2017
In the last few months we have visited 4 times and every time we have tried something different. I got a cake for our anniversary. It was very good. We have tried donuts, nutrolls, cookies, and other baked goods.... all worth the visit. Will definitely return. more »
5on Google, Jul 07, 2017
Best bakery ever an the service always with a smile more »
5on Facebook, Jul 07, 2017
Amazing amazing! I love this place. Their cupcakes and ladylocks r just awesome. I love icing it just makes everything. AWESOME BAKERY! I stop every time I go past lol more »
5on Google, Jul 06, 2017
more »
5on The Knot, Jul 06, 2017
Bethel Bakery has been a staple of my relationship with my husband. He and I always celebrate special occasions with sweets from Bethel. When it came to our wedding cake, we knew there was no other place to look besides Bethel Bakery. Our consultation was amazing, as we tried many different kinds of cake and fillings. We picked out a design, and Bethel Bakery was more than happy to alter the design to suit the theme of our wedding. The wedding cake was amazing, moist, rich, and flavorful. My father even requested more wedding cake at the end of the evening, stating it was the best wedding cake he has ever tasted! I would high recommend Bethel Bakery for your wedding cake needs and I look forward to tasting the top tier of our wedding cake next March for our one year anniversary. I have no doubt it will be just as delicious as it was that day! more »
5on Facebook, Jul 05, 2017
more »
5on Facebook, Jul 05, 2017
The key lime tarts and cannolis are delicious! We will definitely be back! more »
Business Response:
We are glad you enjoyed your visit, Penny!
5on Google, Jul 04, 2017
more »
5on Google, Jul 03, 2017
more »
5on BirdEye, Jul 03, 2017
Never tasted anything sooooooo smooth and fantastic icing and moist cake batter....thanks for coming to north strabane!!! more »
5on Google, Jul 01, 2017
Great cookies and cupcakes more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Anthony!
5on Trip Advisor, Jun 29, 2017
We ordered our wedding cake through Bethel Bakery. It turned out fantastic. The staff were so professional and accommodating. One of our favorite bakeries in the area! more »
5on Google, Jun 28, 2017
Bethel bakery is fenominal more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Susan!
5on Facebook, Jun 27, 2017
more »
5on Google, Jun 26, 2017
Awesome food and cakes. more »
5on Google, Jun 25, 2017
more »
Page 6 of 41


5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Today 7:00 am - 6:00 pm


Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes.

With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna.

Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of the busiest and most beloved purveyors of high-quality baked goods in western Pennsylvania. And they did it while raising seven children, all of whom would eventually work in the family business.

Today, a second generation of the Walsh family manages the bakery. John and his wife, Chris, took over day-to-day operations in 1991and expanded the already extensive inventory of baked goods, but Morris and Anna’s legacy of exceptional quality and customer service lives on.

People travel for miles for a taste of Bethel Bakery’s signature buttercream icing and discriminating brides across the region wouldn’t dream of celebrating their nuptials with anything but a hand-crafted, custom-designed Bethel Bakery cake decorated by one of the shop’s talented designers.

In 2006, Bethel Bakery’s iconic status in the region was recognized by award-winning documentary filmmaker Rick Sebak, who featured the bakery in his WQED program, “What Makes Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.”

In an era driven by convenience and competition from mega-markets and chain stores, Bethel Bakery has endured because it is far more than just a retailer of baked goods—it is an memorable destination experience and a nostalgic reminder of the charms of independent bakeries that were once part of the fabric of every community.
more »

Review summary

5  903
4  86
3  18
1007 reviews