Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Allison C. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I used to not like Maggie's, but since they changed their menu I'm a fan! Personally, I like that they have a huge menu because there's something for everyone. The meals I've had recently I've been impressed with. Their service has also gotten a lot better. I'll definitely be coming back. 

Melissa C. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I've come here a couple times. The bartenders and wait staff have always been nice. My drink orders have always been good. My dinners are always a hit and miss. I've had nachos here and had hair in my nachos (blonde hair and at the time I had green hair). They were polite and gave it to me for free. The food can be over pricey and the menu is a book so a little too big. If I want to eat out it's not here but I don't mind coming here now and then. 

lucas e. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Maggie McFly's was good. We arrived at around 11, just before the lunch rush started. It was perfect timing. The menu is huge. I generally believe that smaller menus mean higher quality food, and vice versa. Regardless, I ordered a french onion soup and chicken ceasar salad. My wife ordered a quesadilla. The food was just fine. Nothing to write home about. It was a good meal, albeit high in sodium. The service was also fine. Our waters were refilled, the server checked on us after we got our food. It was fine. T... read more

Kim S. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

We love this place so much, it's our go to date spot! The menu selection is huge and covers various types of cuisine so my husband and I never have to agree on just one. Delicious food, friendly service, great atmosphere, and we've never had to wait to be seated during the week. Highly recommended! 

Alexandra P. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Last night was my second time at this location and let me tell you it's amazing !!!! Love the new fit menu, helps me stay on track even when I'm dining out.Service and food are supreme. If you want to experience great food and service in CT this is most definitely the spot !!! 

Pollyanna S. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Their menu is RIDICULOUS! So much to choose from it's great! Never had a bad meal here. One thing to keep in mind, we got a kid's pizza for my son & then boyfriend also ordered a pizza for himself. When the food came out, we were in shock! Kids pizza is same size as regular pizza, next time they will share. 

Christine M. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Love this place, great bar menu and happy hour! I always sit at the bar, great vibes and great service. The menu is huge and overwhelming, but something for everyone! The wings here are GREAT! 

B C. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Updated review: The owner contacted us promptly and was extremely professional and offered us a gift card to make up for our experience. We went back and had a much better dining experience this time, although the gift card showed a $0 balance, our server was so polite and helpful, and called HR to fix the issue. Thank you! Iwant to start off saying that my husband, my 19 month old son and I have been to this Maggie McFly's a handful of times and truly enjoy it! We make the drive from Torrington which isn't far for us, but ... read more

Kenzie H. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I have to say, I am not one to typically write reviews, but this place made an amazing impression on me. After a tough night at work, my fiancé and I decided to try Maggie McFly's. We were WOWED by the menu. It felt like there was no shortage of options, especially for a person like me with multiple dietary restrictions. We ended up ordering the panko breaded avocado and let me tell you, after these, you will never go back to fries! YUM! I had the red sangria which was deliciously sweet and had the flavor of a black cherr... read more