Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Amanda C. 

on Yelp

5 months ago

Word to the wise, NEVER order takeout. We've only tried twice, and both times it was a horrible experience. The first time it took the driver almost 2 hours to get the food. First they told him they never received the order. We called and complained and all of a sudden it had magically just come through. Then it took more than an hour for them to give it to the driver. By time we got it, it was cold. We had originally vowed never to do takeout there again. But that was a couple years ago, so we thought we would take a leap o... read more

Tony R. 

on Yelp

7 months ago

Being accused of not leaving a tip (I left 20% cash) because the waiter misplaced it in her own apron pocket then the waiter come to your table to argue with you about it is insane. I agree with leaving tips for good service which the service was good but to do that to customers is so rude, disrespectful and wrong. 1st I left the tip, 2nd I left it in cash for your benefit, 3rd so if someone doesn't leave a tip you think the next step is to accost them at their table when they are getting ready to leave in front of everyone ... read more

Troy S. 

on Yelp

7 months ago

Absolutely disgusting all the way around my daughter and I ordered the Wagyu Burger and the Burger came out like it was in the microwave. The Bread was stale it was just the most disgusting piece of meat I ever has once I took the stale bread off I couldn't even break the Meat with a fork. It was ordered medium. The appetiser was the spinach dip which came with stale chips and the garlic bread was hamburger buns cut into strips. I was upstairs and made my way downstairs to which it was the side of the kitchen I walked down t... read more

Timothy C. 

on Yelp

8 months ago

If I could leave 0 stars for this review I would. I just walked out of the middlebury location with my wife after waiting 20 mins for a table because the hostess gave our table to two people who just walked in. When we asked about why she just gave them our table she said they had a reservation. I guess she didn't realize that we heard the two customers ask for a table for two and didn't mention they had reservations. No accountability what so ever or offer to remedy the situation just told us to wait until another table ope... read more

T T. 

on Yelp

8 months ago

Worst experience ever. Called in advance for dinner for 8. All parties arrived separately, gave the name for the table and they seated us at two separate tables, not even on the same floor. What's the point of giving the name for a reservation if they don't even seat you together? Took almost an hour of everyone sitting there before we realized the rest of the party should have been there at this point. My 80 year old GRANDPARENTS were left alone upstairs for almost an hour before we were able to contact them since they do... read more

Caleb S. 

on Yelp

9 months ago

A cockroach ran across our table. Didn't offer to move us after we told them the first time. Had to wave them in the kitchen once we realized our new table guest hung around for us to grab a photo. Didn't give us a discount or anything after knowing we didn't eat our food afterwards. 

Mark G. 

on Yelp

a year ago

This is the first time I have ever written a bad review for any restaurant in my life. The bartender had ZERO personality. It took her 20 minutes to take our drink order (there were 8 people at the bar) It took another 10 minutes to take our food order. No SMILE, no PERSONALITY!! Ordered water and 10 minutes later got water. Barely ate my dinner and asked for it to be wrapped. Felt it necessary (for the 1st time in my adult life) to write a review on my receipt where we only left a 15% tip....only to find out she thre... read more

Rachel S. 

on Yelp

a year ago

I am a frequent patron of Maggie Mcflys and at numerous locations throughout CT. This particular visit was of my typical experiences at Maggie's with good service, good atmosphere and great food. However, when it came time to pay the bill at the end of the evening my waitress Natalie came to the table to get the check and my credit card to pay the bill. After a bit of waiting, she came back and when I opened the check presenter only the receipt was in there, not my Credit card that I paid with. I asked my waitress where my c... read more

Camille G. 

on Yelp

a year ago

I ordered for takeout today 8/10 and ordered the Pulled Pork tacos with no Salsa verde. When I got home the food was cold and on the tacos was salsa verde. I am very disappointed and will not be coming back.