Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Kenzie H. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I have to say, I am not one to typically write reviews, but this place made an amazing impression on me. After a tough night at work, my fiancé and I decided to try Maggie McFly's. We were WOWED by the menu. It felt like there was no shortage of options, especially for a person like me with multiple dietary restrictions. We ended up ordering the panko breaded avocado and let me tell you, after these, you will never go back to fries! YUM! I had the red sangria which was deliciously sweet and had the flavor of a black cherr... read more

Alex W. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

Been going here for years, started back in my college days of going here for lunch, getting sauced and then heading back to sit in my miserable Eng 101 class. Anyway..... fast forward 20 years, and I enjoying coming here with the wife and kids. The menu is ginormous, so many options to choose from, always fresh and creative ideas coming out of the kitchen. Everything from fish, chicken, huge salads, to healthy kids choice menus, & lots of gluten free options. I highly recommend the Middlebury or Southbury locations. Always ... read more

Laurene M. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

We like going to Maggie's for a few reasons, the most important reason of course is that it has a decent size gluten-free menu. It's also close by, decent quality food and there's never too much of a wait. I wouldn't suggest it if you are looking for a nice quiet dinner because it can get pretty loud but overall it's a very decent place, easy on and off the highway, good amount of parking in very large inside. Nice place to watch a ball game at the bar also 

Edwin S. 

on Yelp

3 weeks ago

My wife and I received gift cards to visit the middlebury CT location near our home. I want to know what I did wrong to the person who gave me these gift cards to go to this location and have a horrible experience. First the calamari was soggy outside and rubbery in the inside. I ordered fish and chips. The fries were over cooked and hard, the fish was ok at first then tasted dry and the cole slaw was dry. The only thing I had that was good was the Stella Beer. my wife ordered the lobster roll she didn't eat all of it and he... read more

Deb K. 

on Yelp

3 weeks ago

I received a terribly small tasteless meal, while my partner received twice the amount of food for the same choice of a meal. substituted a small salad for fries and was charged more. Avoid this restaurant at all costs. The Lager cod fry, was bland and a childs portion. On a scale of 1 to 5 I say -1. 

Jim R. 

on Yelp

2 months ago

it takes a lot for me to waste my time for a review but after they wasted mine so here goes. waited an hour for food. didn't top off drinks. food came at different times, some people in our party finished before others got food. forgot meals altogether. food cold. staff we're not switched on. 

M S. 

on Yelp

3 months ago

The absolute WORST restaurant I've been to probably in my life. It is DIRTY and literally gives you the creeps sitting in there looking at thick dust, cobwebs, sticky tables, and dirty floors. The bathroom is also disgusting and the floor was filled with water, definitely gave outhouse vibes. The service was horrendous! We ordered 2 appetizers, 2 entrees and 1 kids meal. Our appetizers arrived 10 minutes after our entrees-help it make sense! There was no apologies, no explanations nothing. My husband ordered the brisket meal... read more

Skid L. 

on Yelp

4 months ago

Expensive meals now. Not worth it. $21 for frozen fish n chips . Fish was minimal and so were the string fries. 

Lisa C. 

on Yelp

5 months ago

Avoid this location, it's gross. Especially the "brunch" menu. Bathrooms need renovating too it's gross in there.