Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Koren B. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Horrible experience and we will not be back- I ordered 3 sandwiches and 2 side salads tonight $72 for take out - when I got to the car 2 of the 3 meals were I the bag so I had to go back in so that error could be fixed and waited another 15 minutes so the 3rd meal could be made. When I got home the 2 meals that were waiting in the bag that should have been Nashville Hot chicken sandwiches were some version of Chicken cordon bleu- every single order was wrong- how us that even possible? 

Casey S. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Food is average. Service was below average. Called ahead for daughters birthday. They promised something special. Delivered nothing. Disappointing. Others have shared similar experiences. 

Mark M. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

We came here on a Friday at 8:30 pm. The server was attentive, but also snarky and sarcastic. The food and drinks took a very long time to come out, so much so that one of our meals was taken off the bill because it was served at least 15 minutes after all the others. I do not recommend coming here as the quality of the food and the service is not worth the price. 

Alex R. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Ordered chicken and cheese enchiladas through door dash, lost my order took about an hour to find. When they found the order they said it will be around 5 minutes, when I got hiome the rice was uder cook the enchilladas looked and tasted horrible. The mash potatoes were dry an plain. The Dish was around 20 dollars and everything tasted like it came out of a can. No dinner for me last night because of this. 

Luis R. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Ordered a salad online for pick up I get to the restaurant a half hour later I get there wait another half hour while they prepare a salad the I get a message saying order ready for pick up and bartenders just ignore more glance at me but won't interact and ask if I needed help they only help the women since and ignore the men...pervert bartenders 

Nicole J. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Service was TRASH! Let's start with the tables across from us. Patrons politely asked for the bill for their drinks after waiting an hour. After 20 more minutes they put their cash on the table and left... another 5 minutes goes by and they bring the bill to the wrong table. ‍ Next table gets served but with no utensils. So they take them from another table because if they ask it may be another half hour. Third table gets served someone else's food. The correct table has to yell across the patio to get their order. This hap... read more

Katie P. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Not impressed with how down hill this restaurant has gone. I have celiac, and told them my dinner was for a gluten allergy (easier to understand). I got my dish with gluten free pasta (supposedly). It tasted firm and I thought it was cooked well. I got very sick. It was either regular pasta or gluten free pasta cooked in the same water. I got shrimp and scallops, and for 30.00 I got bay scallops. They were clearly frozen. Also, they were was little alcohol in our drinks (if any). Service was very slow, and they clearly forgo... read more

Rebecca H. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Ordered food to be delivered. The apple crisp "dessert" was three pieces of apple. Not worth $8. 

Will M. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

With two starving girls while driving back from AAU basketball, we figured the original Maggie's was a safe (if uninspired) bet. Man we're we wrong. I'll preface the rest of this by saying that I grew up in Naugatuck, and I've been periodically stopping into this particular restaurant for 25 plus years. Our server, Whitney, tried to play the cool server card by not writing anything down. She promptly forgot my drink order. When I told her what it was, she disappeared for ten plus minutes, and returned without it again. ... read more