ABOUT DR. KOTLUS – NYC OCULOPLASTIC SURGEON AND COSMETIC FACIAL SURGEON Brett Kotlus, MD is a top-rated NYC oculoplastic and facial cosmetic surgeon. He is fellowship-trained in both oculoplastic surgery and cosmetic surgery. He has performed thousands of cosmetic procedures. Dr. Kotlus received a Master’s degree in Genetics from the Pennsylvania State University and his medical degree from the Sackler School of Medicine. After completing his residency at the North Shore-Long Island Jewish Health System of the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, he completed two accredited fellowships in Oculofacial Plastic Surgery and General Cosmetic Surgery in Tucson, Arizona. He subsequently served

BIRDEYE FOR BUSINESSES

This profile is powered by BirdEye. Over 50,000 businesses use BirdEye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. BirdEye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about BirdEye

5.0

★★

386 reviews

5★379

4★2

3★0

2★0

1★0

5 reviews have no rating

149 Reviews5.0Google
125 Reviews5.0Realself
46 Reviews5.0RateMDs
Show All

Write a review

Reviews(250)

Google Reviews(149)

Sort By:

5 results available.

Recommended

Guy_in_NYC on Realself

★★

2 months ago

Dr. Kotlus performed my lower blepharoplasty, and I have been extremely happy with the procedure and the results. I’m a 43 year-old male, and had moderate lower eye bags that I found very bothersome. I was often asked if I was tired, or if I had slept well. Thankfully, that is no longer a problem. Throughout the process, Dr. Kotlus has been very generous with his time. I never felt rushed during our visits, and when I requested a second consultation before deciding on surgery, he accommodated the appointment and re-explained the entire procedure and post-op care to my partner. He never up-sold me on other procedures, add-ons or products. In fact, when I asked about adding a laser treatment to the procedure he was honest and said I didn’t need it. The day of surgery I didn’t know what to expect. This was my first cosmetic surgery, and it could not have been easier. The anesthesiologist was great and described in detail his portion of the procedure. Dr. Kotlus then came in to assure me everything would be easy, and it was. I knew exactly what to do post-op, as everything had been explained in detail. Dr. Kotlus and team also called multiple times to check-in and made sure I was recovering well and not in any pain. At my 1 week post-op appointment everything looked great. I didn’t really bruise, which is apparently uncommon. A welcome surprise. I have met with Dr. Kotlus for post-op appointments at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months and 6 months. At 3 months I had a small amount of Botox to reduce some fine lines, separate to my eye surgery. At 6 months I inquired about some fillers, and again he told me I didn’t need them. His honesty has been very appreciated. If you are considering eye surgery, I would highly recommend meeting with Dr. Kotlus. I saw three of the top NYC oculoplastic surgeons and I knew right away that I wanted him to perform my surgery. There are a lot of amazing surgeons in New York, and ultimately it comes down to whom you feel most comfortable performing your surgery. I am very happy with my choice.

ar2802 on Realself

★★

2 months ago

I was unhappy with the bags I had under my eyes and decided to have them removed. My problem was which doctor could I use. I went on the internet and searched for plastic surgeons who perform these types of surgery. One name stood out with perfect reviews. That Doctor was Brett Kotlus. After reading as many reviews as I could, I called his office and set up a consultation. I decided to go with Dr. Kotlus and I made the right choice. He did a phenomenal job. No more bags and it’s only been four weeks since the surgery and I couldn’t be happier. THANK YOU DR. KOTLUS!!!

Kimd200 on Realself

★★

2 months ago

Dr Kotlus was everything my research said he would be. Talented, gentle, artistic, kind, patient, conservative, trustworthy, honest and thorough. First time getting filler under my eyes, in the marionette lines and nasal labial folds and botox around my eyes. I am overjoyed with the results and highly recommend him.

gailhoff on Realself

★★

3 months ago

I can’t say enough about Dr. Kotlus and his team. From the moment I arrived the staff was courteous and professional, they put me at ease and kept me well informed. Dr. Kotlus was wonderful, he explained the procedure and what I should expect afterwards. His instructions for pre and post procedure care were clear and concise and made everything simple. I was also pleased at how little discomfort and lack of bruising I experienced. I couldn’t be happier with the process or the results.

francescaC on Realself

★★

4 months ago

I cannot say enough about Dr. Brett Kotlus - he is truly a doctor that can be trusted. He is skilled. Knew exactly what he was doing. I researched and met with several top-rated doctors. I am patting myself on the back for being smart enough and lucky enough to choose Dr. Kotlus. My case was particularly difficult because not only did I have a revision on my lower eyelids due to a previous surgery that was completely correct, I also had ptosis on both upper eyelids. Dr. Kotlus accomplished all that he told me he would, plus he suggested fat grafting in the hollow between my eyes and my cheeks. I look amazing. There was hardly any bruising. Even his choice of the anesthesiologist was wonderful.The whole experience was positive. His staff is very helpful. He was very fair in his pricing, especially since my case was more complicated. My eyes are still a bit swollen but they already look phenomenal. I am not an easy person to get a 5-star review from - if I didn't think the Dr./product is good, I would NEVER give such a great review. I knew in my heart that I could trust Dr. Kotlus and I was right. I highly recommend this doctor - a doctor in a very good sense of the word.

mt0201 on Realself

★★

4 months ago

Went for under eye filler (and botox for good measure). I decided to wait a couple of weeks to write my review just to see how everything settled (it takes time for mild swelling to go down and see true results). Dr. Kotlus was very informative throughout the entire process. He is not trying to maximize the amount of money he can squeeze out of you and will be honest with you if he thinks you do not need something done. I had gone to another doctor for similar procedures in the past who always tried to up-sell patients, and I am so happy I found Dr. Kotlus. He is fantastic, extremely talented (particularly in the eye area), and I've already recommend him to my friends and family.

mishc42 on Realself

★★

6 months ago

I had a fantastic experience and I love my new look! At every step, Dr. Kotlus was very attentive, friendly, and had professional expertise. I highly recommend him for upper bleph, my results look very natural and fresh. I was very nervous about undergoing the procedure but I'm so glad I decided to go with Dr. Kotlus. The staff were all very friendly and welcoming, and Dr. Kotlus was very patient and easy to speak with. I couldn't be happier with how it turned out!

Anonymous on RateMDs

★★

7 months ago

I can’t say enough good things about Dr Kotlus. I ‘m not ready for surgery yet, but went to him for injectables/fillers when he was practicing in Michigan. I just flew out to NYC to see him again because he spoiled me. Two other doctors didn’t even come close to what this doctor does with fillers. He is a true artist and well worth the added-on price of a plane ticket from Michigan. He is personable, professional, and honest in what he can and can’t do for you. I love his work and will definitely be back. HIGHLY recommended!

Kat on Healthgrades

★★

7 months ago

I saw Dr. Kotlus for injectable about five years ago, in Michigan, before he moved to NYC. I actually flew to his NYC office because he spoiled me god anyone else. He is an artist, and I couldn’t be happier with my results. He is truthful, telling you what he can or cannot achieve with fillers and/or surgery and why. He is personable, professional, and I will be back to see him again. I highly recommend him, and his office staff is lovely as well.