Redeye Grill

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Horrible service and even worse food! The waiter told us the seafood was on sale and took forever to get orders in. We all were sick the next AM 

WENDY 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Food has not maintained its quality in the 12 years we have been coming here. Lobster roll subpar. Service was ok not great. 

jsau 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Red eye Grill was in a good location for Carnegie Hall. It had a reasonable menu although some of the standard items e.g. Tiramisu, fish were unavailable which was a surprise as we were eating early at 17:45. I had a soup which was very bland and indescribable but my husband's squid was good and plentiful. For mains we had chicken and the burger both of which were average. The food came so rapidly that we'd hardly put our cutlery down before the next course arrived - far too quick. Also the serving staff seemed to be rushing... read more

PaulB 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Loud, poor service and mediocre food.....priced liked the opposite. In a city with plenty of steak houses this should be off the list. 

lydial 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

If you don't have men sitting at your table don't go. The waiters only pay attention to them. Because we hadn't ordered drinks or bottles of wine (people who did were attended to beautifully) we sat for 25 minutes before we ordered and sat with dirty dishes in front of us for 20. I'm allergic to shellfish and ordered the lamb chops, after the order was taken the manager (who took our order because the waiter was busy - probably pouring wine) told me he had forgotten but they had run out of lamb chops and to order something e... read more

JimH 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Very disappointing - we took out of town guests for brunch. Three eggs came with one piece of dry toast, no butter or jam. Had to ask for spoons for our soup. Food was sent back because it was not warm. Won't go back. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Service was inconsistent and my wife's lobster roll tasted over cooked and a bit like freezer burn. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Rushed service. Not attentive. Would not return. Unhappy 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Service was comically bad. The prices are obscene relative to average food quality. This is a 20 year old restaurant that survives solely on the basis of proximity to theater/Carnegie Hall. It needs a refresh in every way.