Maggie McFly's | Albany

Gerry L. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Do not got there - ever. I have tried take out orders there twice. I blame myself for giving them a second chance. I showed up for my take out order. They received the order but did not place the order. Who does this? They waited for me to arrive to actually submit my order, even though they had it. People place. Take out order and expect it to be ready to be picked up. They told me it would be 20 minutes - just enough time to order a drink and wait at the bar. I did not fall for this. I should have just walked out but... read more

Morgan L. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

We had to ask the waiter to serve us after like 20 minutes of sitting with no drinks or anything. The waiter looked confused and they had to go talk to the host who told them that we were one of their tables. There were only 2 other parties seated so it was odd that they got confused. The food was fine but nothing crazy. It tasted like food that was probably pre-made and frozen beforehand or something. Not terrible, but with the combination of poor service and mediocre food I don't think I'll be back. 

Joey S. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Below average everything tbh. Looks like it could be a fun happy hour spot but the it was really bad all around. 

Kendric R. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I believe this place has the potential to be a really good dining experience, just not now. Like most businesses, staffing there is an issue and no place was that more apparent than in the kitchen. Quality control there is definitely an issue. I think I will patron the establishment again. Just not in the near future. They got work to do. 

Jack S. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

This was the worst fucking place I've ever been at. Our pizza was fucking tiny, Our fries were soggy, and worst of all it smelled like a literal rhinoceros's ass hole. I wish I could give a lower star. 

Michele V. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Ordered farmers salad to go Mixed greens, beets, asparagus,pecans and goat cheese. Take a good look at the photo. How is this acceptable? Either the guy in the kitchen has to go or the whole restaurant does. 

Courtney W. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Where do I begin? It was a group of 5 & when we entered the establishment (it was our first time all from different parts of the world) the greeting host said it was a 25-30min wait. That was accurate just to be seated! We were so hungry the menu looked interesting simply because it had everything you could imagine (how'd the kitchen keep up with so many options) We were seated the waitress took our drink orders we got them in an HOUR. After physically going to the bar and requesting the drinks be made. So, now the manager... read more

Aarti R. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Never again. I went to Maggie McFly's on Memorial Day. It was surprisingly empty when we walked in at about 12:30. In spite of the massive restaurant and several open tables, we were told it would be a 25 minute wait. At first we thought it was due to social distancing which would have been understandable, but I overheard two employees saying that a few other employees had called out. We got a spot at the bar which offered the full menu on a first-come-first-serve basis. The bar was open and airy and empty. It took our ... read more

Deena Y. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Absolutely disappointed! walked in at 11:07pm when the restaurant closed at 12am. The restaurant ambiance was nice and was empty with only few customers. We were seated and given a couple of menus. We selected our meals and waited waited waited for the waitress to come by and take our orders.. unfortunately that took over 20min. I ordered a lava cake and tea. The tea arrived without any sugar, milk, etc. the lava cake was very dry and without "lava molten chocolate" inside. I also ordered fries. My friend ordered a burger bu... read more