Redeye Grill

Sandman 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Overpriced, average food. Surly service. Not our first time here but feeling more like Red Lobster than fine dining these days. 

GuillermoC 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Excellent service. Shellfish appetizers were delicious. We were rather disappointed in our main entrees. 

Paul 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Red Eye is a traditional standby for me and members of my fellow performing arts groups at Carnegie Hall. Tonight was a true shock. The menu has changed. Prices are in the stratosphere. Who is the Red Eye kidding. It ain't Le Bernardin! In previous visits one could find an eclectic menu with, at the low end, hamburgers and a few pasta dishes. Now almost all entrees are $40 and above. I did ask the waiter about the menu and was informed that it had changed. I inquired about late night, one time entrees, and was then informed ... read more

hjcz 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Disappointing experience....small portions and very over priced. Not worth it! 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Expensive. Brought wrong food. Steak cooked wrong. 

needhamom 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

The only saving grace for this over-priced "tourist trap" is that it is close to Carniege Hall. Like it's sister restaurant Tratatoria del Arte it is priced for tourists who unsuspectingly make their way up from Times Square. 

jayworth 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Poor service from incompetent waiter who was forgetful & spoke poor English. Recent menu changes eliminated some favorites and changed others. The lobster cobb salad had so little lobster it didn't deserve the name; particularly @ $38. Red Eye had been a great choice for before Carnegie Hall, etc - we probably won't go back. 

Rhea58 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

The main room was packed for our 6pm reservation, so we opted to dine in side room. We did not immed. order wine but chose 3 appetizers to share. When wine was ordered it was not served & we felt that since we ordered 3 apps we were given poor service. As for the food - the chowder, crabcake & quacamole for 2 were all good. However would not return as main courses are way over priced. As it was our meal was over $100 for w/1 glass of wine that was finally served. 

TonyC 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We chose Redeye for dinner prior to attending a concert at Carnegie Hall. Located just across the street, the location was ideal. The service and food were both both good but not great. We felt the food was overpriced for what is was. Although we had made the reservation a week prior, we were seated at a table for two that was small and barely tucked in between a large round with a big group and an empty table set for four. Overall, it was not a bad experience but it was not that good either. With the many great dining optio... read more